We recommend you visit the interactive version. The text to the right is provided for printing purposes.
|
"It's not magic,"
the physicist Doyne Farmer once said about the phenomenon known as emergence,
"but it feels like magic."
Creatures, cities, and storms self-organize, with low-level rules giving rise
to higher-level sophistication. Entirely new properties and behaviors
"emerge," with no one directing and no one able to foresee the new
characteristics from knowledge of the constituents alone. The whole is truly
greater than the sum of its parts. In the
following 10 examples, see how emergence pervades our everyday lives. (For the
inevitable questions you'll have, we suggest you Ask the
Expert).—Peter Tyson
|
|
Bird flock A flock of birds hundreds strong
wheeling in perfect synchrony overhead is one of nature's great sights.
If a single bird fell out of line, utter confusion could ensue, yet none does.
Harmony reigns, spawning a behavior (flocking, with its swift motion and sudden
course changes) that is not predictable from knowing all there is to know about
any single bird. Flocking "emerges" from simple rules instinctively
followed by each bird: keep a precise distance away from and stay aligned with
your nearest neighbors, and avoid predators. The "wave" in a
stadium operates along similar lines (minus the predator part).
|
|
|
Ant colony Ants are not mental giants, and
they can't see the big picture. Yet out of their simple
behaviors—follow the strongest pheromone trail, say, or save the queen at
all costs when under attack—arises a classic example of emergence: the
ant colony. The colony exhibits an extraordinary ability to explore and exploit
its surroundings. It is aware of and reacts to food sources, floods, enemies,
and other phenomena, over a substantial piece of ground. Each ant dies after
days or months, but the colony survives for years, becoming more stable and
organized over time.
|
|
|
Slime mold Turn over a rotting log in a forest
and you might see a fungus-like blob coating a patch of the decomposing wood.
Return the next day and it might have vanished. Where did it go? Nowhere. It is
Dictyostelium discoideum, the slime
mold. For most of its life, the slime mold exists as thousands of single-celled
organisms, invisible to the naked eye as they dine on decaying leaves and wood.
But when weather conditions become less than ideal, those cells band together,
forming a single entity—"they" become an "it."
If you used time-lapse photography, you could
actually see the macroorganism crawl along, slow as a starfish.
|
|
|
Water A molecule of water is as basic as
it gets—just an oxygen atom with two hydrogen atoms adhering to it. But
throw a jillion of them together, and voilà, you get a substance with characteristics that the individual molecules do not possess on their
own—liquidity, for instance. Emergent properties often beget emergent
behaviors, and those of water are no exception. Cool water down enough
and it becomes a solid, for instance; warm it up enough and it becomes a gas.
|
|
|
Hurricane Take a small atmospheric
disturbance whirling around in a stretch of warm tropical ocean, at least
80°F. Make sure it's 300 miles or more from the equator so
it's sufficiently stirred by the Earth's rotation. Season it with
evaporating seawater, which condenses when it rises high enough into the
atmosphere. Lower the atmospheric pressure near the surface. What do you get?
The emergent happening known as a hurricane, with its emergent attributes
(e.g., winds of at least 74 miles per hour) and its emergent behaviors (e.g.,
an ability to suddenly alter course).
|
|
|
City Cities have a remarkable ability to
self-organize as they grow. Neighborhoods of like-minded people and similar
kinds of businesses establish themselves organically, from the bottom up. Thus,
New York gained Chinatown and Little Italy, the Garment District and the Flower
District, enclaves that appeared regardless of such top-down forces as
planning commissions and zoning laws. Such communities-within-the-community
emerge on their own, lending cities their distinctive personalities.
|
|
|
Stock market In the 17th century, the economist
Adam Smith described an "invisible hand" that guides markets to
produce just the amount and variety of goods that the public needs. The stock
market has its own "invisible hand." The purely self-interested
actions of thousands of buyers and sellers result in the purely blind workings
of the stock market—the sudden shifts in activity and valuations, the
bubbles and crashes—as well as the market's notorious properties of stupendous
intricacy and frustrating unpredictability.
|
|
|
Chess There's hardly a better
example of emergence than chess. Out of a game with fewer than two dozen rules
comes complexity to challenge the greatest minds on Earth. As the emergence
expert John Holland notes, if you have a game that ends after 50 moves and
offers 10 possible moves from any configuration along the way—a length of
game and number of options roughly equivalent to that found in chess—you
will have 1050 ways of playing the game, "a number," he
says, "which substantially exceeds the number of atoms in the whole of
our planet Earth."
|
|
|
Consciousness For some experts, the mind is the
ultimate exemplar of emergence. Your brain contains several billion neurons
that perform a very simple function: relaying electrical messages across
synapses to their neighbors. It's a physical action, yet out of their
collective firings somehow arises a psychological phenomenon—the
conscious mind. Can consciousness be reduced to the interactions of neurons?
Experts have no way of knowing, because the brain is orders of magnitude more
complex than any computer today, making answering that question at present
difficult if not impossible.
|
|
|
Life Are you an emergent phenomenon? Consider this: At any given
time, some 75 trillion cells are doing their thing in your body. But they are
constantly dying and being replaced by new ones, such that in less than two
years you won't have a single cell you have today. Yet you remain you. How is this possible? Even though each of
your cells contains your entire genome, you would hardly say that any one of
your cells constitutes you. But taken together they amount to
you. Life, says the theoretical biologist Stuart Kauffman, is indeed an
emergent event.
|
|
|