GUEST: My doll has been in the family for at least 50 years. And before that, I'm not sure where exactly she was. I was told that she was a French fashion doll. My parents were antiquers. On Sundays, they would go to different antique shops in Massachusetts, and because I was the youngest, I got to go, too. Not very long into that, I hated it. One Sunday-- I used to stand in the corner while my parents would look at all the furniture-- there was this doll, and my mother said, "Do you like it?" And I said, "Oh, yeah, I really like it." So they bought it, took it home. It was my doll, but I wasn't allowed to play with it.
APPRAISER: (chuckles)
GUEST: It was put behind glass and I could look at it. We knew that she was probably worth a lot of money, since it's the original outfit. So we took it to this doll hospital, and that was kind of creepy. The man that came to the door was very interesting-looking. And we walked in, and the dolls were all in pieces, and they were all staring at you because they're all hanging on the walls. And it was very dark-- it was just not pleasant. And then there was another man there who had a very long beard, and he looked at the doll and he said, "Can we keep her to evaluate her?"
APPRAISER: Mm-hmm.
GUEST: Week later, they called us and said, "You've got to come down, you got to come down! This is the highest-priced doll we've ever saw!" "Really?" So we went down, and they said, "She's worth $16,000." And we went, "Okay." And just kind a... So then, a few years later, we went to this wannabe ROADSHOW-- it was not the ANTIQUES ROADSHOW-- and we had her evaluated again, and they told me it was worth $3,000. My hus... And they wanted to purchase her. And my husband said, "Oh, no, she's worth $16,000."
APPRAISER: (chuckles)
GUEST: And again, it was, like, "Really?"
APPRAISER: It's very inappropriate and unethical...
GUEST: Really?
APPRAISER: ...in our business to offer to buy something after we appraised it. This is a little doll made by Schmitt and Fils of Paris, France, so she is a French doll. She's not a French fashion doll, as you describe, but she's actually a French bébé. She's in her original French costume with her little straw hat, her little lace dress, her wonderful socks, and her original labeled shoes. She's made of bisque, and she has paperweight eyes and a composition body. When we turn her around, we will see that she is marked. And it's very difficult to see under her little wig, but there's a little shield mark that stands for Schmitt.
GUEST: Okay.
APPRAISER: And then we have "000."
GUEST: I saw that.
APPRAISER: And then also on her bottom, we would see that it's marked the same way. She has pierced ears with her most likely original turquoise earrings. These dolls were made in the 1880s, and they were sold as the finest French dolls.
GUEST: Oh, fabulous.
APPRAISER: Beautifully made. Very excited to see her. So now we need to decide if the fake appraisal fair or the weird man with the long beard is right about her value.
GUEST: (laughs): Okay.
APPRAISER: A little doll like this, at retail, would sell for $16,000 to $18,000.
GUEST: Oh, my goodness.
APPRAISER: I've even seen ‘em at auction sell for more.
GUEST: Wow.
APPRAISER: Very desirable, high-end doll.
GUEST: Well, I guess I shouldn't have laughed. (chuckles)
